Photo: Mokhnatkin Sergey Evgenevich
died under investigation

Personal Information

Birth date
6 мар. 1954 г. (66 years old)
Death date
28 мая 2020 г.
Special circumstances
activist, human rights defender
Notes
He graduated from the Izhevsk Mechanical Institute with a degree in computer programming. He worked as an engineer-economist. For two years, he taught industrial production management at a university, then went into business; in the 1980s, he worked in the North as a laborer, foreman, and engineer. In the 1990s, he was involved in private enterprise. Since the 2000s, he has attended rallies and court hearings in support of Khodorkovsky and Lebedev.

Mokhnatkin Sergey Evgenevich

Added: 26 февр. 2025 г.

Case Information

Region of case initiation:
Moscow, Arkhangelsk Oblast
Detention date:
31 дек. 2009 г.
Charges:
Art. 318 CC RF Part 2, Art. 319 CC RF, Art. 321 CC RF Part 2, Art. 297 CC RF Part 1
Sentence:
2 years and 6 months in a general-security prison, 4 years and 6 months in a maximum-security prison, 2 years and 4 months in a maximum-security prison, 2 years and 6 months in a maximum-security prison; the case was dismissed
Lawyer:
Makarov Vyacheslav Gennadevich, Krikun Leonid Leonidovich
Court that passed the sentence:
Tverskoy District Court of Moscow, Judicial Precinct No. 4 of the Kotlas Judicial District, Arkhangelsk Region, Kotlas City Court, Arkhangelsk Region
Judge who passed the sentence:
Kovalevskaya Aleksandra B., Dolinina Olga Ivanovna, Shikin Sergey Viktorovich
Case on the court website:
kotlasgrsud.arh.sudrf.ru
Appeal court:
Moscow City Court, Kotlas City Court, Arkhangelsk Region, Arkhangelsk Regional Court
Appeal judge:
Kolominova Yuliya Viktorovna, Grigencha Viktor Yanovich
Estimated release date:
18 сент. 2019 г.

Case Description

On December 31, 2009, in Moscow, on Triumph Square, during a rally in support of Article 31 of the Constitution organized by Eduard Limonov, 55-year-old Sergei Mokhnatkin was detained. He was not participating in the rally but was simply passing by. Right before his eyes, police officers roughly detained a woman who was also just a passerby. He couldn’t help but comment on what was happening, and as a result, he was detained as well.

While Mokhnatkin was at the police station, he wrote several statements claiming that he had been beaten by the police; however, he never received a response to them.

On January 11, 2010, a criminal case was filed against Mokhnatkin for using violence against a law enforcement officer. According to the investigation, while in the police van, Mokhnatkin saw a police officer filming him, started a fight with him, and broke his nose.

On February 26, 2010, investigators placed the suspect under a travel ban.

On June 1, 2010, the day after another “Strategy-31” protest, the man was remanded to a pretrial detention center. In protest, he went on a hunger strike and remained on hunger strike for all 8 days leading up to the trial. While in the pretrial detention center, he was beaten by Federal Penitentiary Service officers because he refused to be photographed or undergo fingerprinting.

On June 9, 2010, the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow found Sergei Mokhnatkin guilty and sentenced him to 2.5 years of imprisonment in a general-regime penal colony.

On August 16, 2010, the Moscow City Court upheld the sentence.

On April 23, 2012, Russian President Dmitry Medvedev signed a decree pardoning Mokhnatkin without requiring him to admit guilt.

On December 31, 2013, in Moscow on Triumph Square during the traditional “Strategy-31” protest, Mokhnatkin was detained again by police officers. An administrative offense report was filed against him, but he was not released from the police station. The next day, at the Tverskoy District Investigative Department, Mokhnatkin was charged with using violence that did not endanger the life or health of a law enforcement officer.

The Ministry of Internal Affairs claims that Mokhnatkin “resisted police officers and, in doing so, inflicted bodily injury on a colonel and a female officer of the Second Operational Regiment.” The police noted that both officers underwent medical examinations; the woman—a senior police sergeant with the 2nd Operational Regiment—was diagnosed with soft tissue contusions to her face.

Mokhnatkin himself denied any wrongdoing and claimed that during the peaceful protest, he approached Colonel Sergei Shorin and asked a question about illegal detentions. When the activist introduced himself, the colonel allegedly ordered that the “provocateur be removed” and struck Mokhnatkin in the face at least twice. To support this account, civic activists have presented photographs taken on Triumfalnaya Street: they show the colonel nearly choking the activist as he is being shoved into a police van. Inside the van, other detainees insist, Mokhnatkin continued to be beaten.

On January 2, 2014, Judge Elena Stashina of the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow (who is on the “Magnitsky List”) ordered the activist’s arrest for two months. Stashina rejected all of the defense’s motions and refused to allow witnesses to be called to court (activists Ildar Dadin, Mikhail Udimov, and Yuri Chaldaev, who had been detained alongside Mokhnatkin, were prepared to testify) and refused to postpone the hearing so that the defense attorneys could gather the necessary character references and sureties.

On December 10, 2014, the Tverskoy District Court of Moscow found Sergei Mokhnatkin guilty and sentenced him to 4.5 years of imprisonment in a maximum-security penal colony.

On April 3, 2015, the Moscow City Court upheld the sentence.

In September 2015, a third criminal case was brought against Mokhnatkin in Kotlas, Arkhangelsk Oblast. He was charged with publicly insulting a government official in connection with the performance of his official duties.

According to the investigation, on September 24 and 25, 2015, while serving his sentence at Correctional Colony No. 4, Mokhnatkin publicly insulted the head of the rehabilitation unit by directing profanity and obscene language at him. It is alleged that he did so out of dissatisfaction with the fact that, at the officer’s initiative, disciplinary measures had previously been imposed on him for violating the rules governing the serving of his sentence. The following day, the convict repeated his insults during a commission meeting in the colony warden’s office.

On June 3, 2016, Olga Dolilina, a magistrate of Judicial District No. 4 of the Kotlas Judicial District in the Arkhangelsk Region, Olga Dolilina, found Sergey Mokhnatkin guilty of committing two separate crimes and sentenced him to 11 months of correctional labor, with 10% of his earnings to be withheld as revenue for the state. By partially combining the unserved portion of his sentence from the previous conviction, the court ultimately sentenced him to 2 years and 5 months of imprisonment in a strict-regime correctional colony.

On November 29, 2016, the Kotlas City Court of the Arkhangelsk Region reclassified the two separate incidents as a single continuing offense and imposed a sentence of 8 months of correctional labor, with 10% of his earnings withheld. The total prison term, taking into account the previous sentence, was reduced to 2 years and 4 months to be served in a maximum-security penal colony.

No later than September 2016, another criminal case was filed against Mokhnatkin. He was accused of disrupting the operations of a correctional facility by using violence—which did not endanger the life or health of a correctional facility employee—against that employee.

According to the investigation, on March 4, 2016, in the search room of Correctional Colony No. 4, Mokhnatkin, who was serving his sentence there, categorically refused to be transported to a pretrial detention center for questioning in a case involving insulting a government official and demonstratively lay down on the floor. When the guards decided to escort the man to a special vehicle and carried him by his arms and legs toward the exit, he resisted, struggled to break free, and deliberately punched one of them in the face, causing the officer pain and a nosebleed.

Mokhnatkin himself claimed that he had been repeatedly beaten by Federal Penitentiary Service (FSIN) officers while in the prison colony. According to the activist, they had no right to transfer him from the prison colony to the pretrial detention center—this constitutes a violation of his sentence. According to Mokhnatkin, he was not allowed to review the new criminal case in accordance with the Code of Criminal Procedure; his signature on the review documents was forged; and there was no court order authorizing the transfer. For refusing to comply with an illegal demand, he was beaten so severely that his spine was broken: “Several officers kicked me hard on the floor, and one burly guy (about 100 kilograms) slammed his knee into my back, right on my lower back—I immediately felt the fracture. The pain is intense. It’s better to have your arms or legs broken than your spine. I even wished I could lose consciousness while he was standing with that knee on my already broken spine,” Mokhnatkin later recounted.

On March 20, 2017, the Kotlas City Court in the Arkhangelsk Region found Sergei Mokhnatkin guilty in a new case and sentenced him to 2 years of imprisonment. By partially combining the sentences, taking into account the punishment from his previous conviction, the court ultimately sentenced the man to 2 years and 6 months of imprisonment in a strict-regime correctional colony.

On June 2, 2017, the Criminal Division of the Arkhangelsk Regional Court upheld the sentence.

On December 2, 2018, the opposition activist was due to be released, but on November 16, 2018, a fifth criminal case was opened against Mokhnatkin—he was again charged with contempt of court and disrupting the operations of a correctional facility through the use or threat of violence that did not endanger life or health.

According to the investigation, Mokhnatkin, while participating via video link in a court hearing to establish administrative supervision, publicly directed crude and indecent insults at the prosecutor. It is also alleged that during another incident inside the correctional hospital, when inspectors and guards began conducting a personal search of the defendant prior to his transfer, he swung his wooden cane at them. He then threatened to use violence, insulted the prison staff, spat at them twice, and punched one of the guards in the leg.

On November 29, 2018, the Isakogorsk District Court of Arkhangelsk ordered the defendant to be held in pretrial detention.

On December 14, 2018, the Arkhangelsk Regional Court overturned the Isakogorsk District Court’s decision to arrest Mokhnatkin; he was released that same evening.

In November 2019, Mokhnatkin began experiencing complications from an injury sustained while at Arkhangelsk Penal Colony No. 4, when Federal Penitentiary Service officers broke his spine. On December 3, 2019, the activist was admitted to the hospital in serious condition: his legs had failed him, he could only lie on one side, and it was impossible to turn him onto his other side or onto his back due to excruciating pain; painkillers were ineffective. According to his relatives, it was only with the help of human rights defenders that they were able to secure his hospitalization.

The court twice remanded Mokhnatkin’s case to the prosecutor due to gross violations of procedural rules. Ultimately, the case was suspended due to the human rights defender’s serious illness.

On May 28, 2020, Sergei Mokhnatkin died in Moscow at the age of 67.

On July 25, 2022, the Isakogorsk District Court of Arkhangelsk dismissed the criminal case following the activist’s death.

On November 22, 2022, the Arkhangelsk Regional Court upheld the lower court’s ruling.